Thursday, April 11, 2013

Windhorst-Pat Riley Best Executive Column Analysis


Riley won his first ring as an executive in 2012


In this column, Windhorst takes a look at the executive of the year race in the NBA and makes a case for Miami’s Pat Riley, who he considers as a longshot to win the award despite his team’s success and his big summer in 2010.

Windhorst begins his feature column by informing the reader that Pat Riley did not win the executive of the year award following his acquisition of the Big Three (James, Wade, and Bosh) nor is he considered to be the front runner to win the award this year.  While Windhorst depicts his opinions in the column and names Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey as the likeliest winner of the award this year, Windhorst exhibits a pro-Riley bias through his analysis of Riley’s newer acquisitions and use of well-placed quotes. In particular, the Daryl Morey quote, "Pat Riley should win every year for getting LeBron James," gives Windhorst credibility after establishing Morey’s strong case for the award. In addition, Windhorst examines the 2011 executive of the year race in which Pat Riley came in second to the Chicago Bulls despite his ”generational coup” of signing LeBron James, Chris Bosh, and Dwyane Wade.

Windhorst’s ability to contrast the 2011 and 2013 award races and successfully analyze Riley’s lesser impact moves, such as the Shane Battier, Ray Allen, and Chris Anderson signings, makes his argument very compelling.  In 2011, Riley tied Bulls GM Gar Forman, each receiving 11 votes, but Chicago Bulls president John Paxson also received 3 votes. While Miami made the big name free agent signings in the summer of 2010, Chicago hired Coach Tom Thibodeau, made a number of smaller impact signings highlighted by Carlos Boozer, and clinched the top seed in the Eastern Conference. Thus, Pat Riley has a case to win the award this year in spite of a relatively low key offseason due to his team’s strong and improving play.

After reading this article, I wonder if a similar story will be told of the Los Angeles Lakers General Manager Mitch Kupchak in a few years. While Kupchak clearly made the sexiest moves this past off-season by acquiring Dwight Howard and Steve Nash, the Lakers have not lived up to expectations on the court this season. If the Lakers resign Howard and live up to the lofty expectations set for them in 2013-2014, Kupchak could have a strong case to win the award in the future by sticking with a team of stars he put together this season.

No comments:

Post a Comment